We really liked this set too. I would have to agree that the skate guards do fall off quite easily and AG should make an attacment piece like with real skate guards. The medal is well weighted and sits quite nicely on the doll. I do prefer the performance dress to the warm up outfit's fit. I find that the leotard could be a bit looser in spots only to ensure a more accomidating fit, although I wouldn't discredit this set because of it.
Honestly I give the set an A! My dd#3 loves it on her JLY#25!