I think the rating for this outfit would definitely change from person to person. I LOVE this outfit, but only because it brings back good memories of when I was younger. It is the outfit my doll came in, and my friend and I used to dress up our dolls as "twins" in it. So, I'd say if you're looking on eBay for retired outfits to buy, this isn't necessarily worth it, but it's a keeper for me. I still give it an A.