I got two of these at AGPC when it was a PWP outfit. I have to say, I really love this outfit.
Dress/jumper - I really like the style of the top of this dress. It looks a bit more "grown-up" and I think the pleating at the top is unique, plus I love the empire waist. Your doll could wear it to a holiday celebration or to a school dance, with or without the turtleneck (I think it looks good both ways). The fabric is kind-of thin but it has a soft velvet brocade which I like. My main complaint with the fabric is that it wrinkles easily; mine were wrinkled when I bought them. Grade: B+
Turtleneck - Very versatile... it could go with a lot of things, not just the dress. It's made of a thin knit fabric. I have turtlenecks made out of similar fabric (in my size, of course!) so I didn't think it was that unusual. Grade: A
Shoes - Again, go with everything! They also stay on which is a plus. I don't really have any complaints about them. Grade: A+
Hair clips - Cute, generic AG clips. Grade: B
Overall Grade: A-
Kit-Kat compare turtleneck vs. no turtleneck:
Cate wears the turtleneck with the skirt from Molly's Sweater and Skirt outfit: