I pawed over this dress when I bought it for a friend, enough to decide that I would not want it for my own collection. I like the concept. But I think the plaid fabric is way too thin and the dress itself is way too short. I think the dress only looks right when paired with some sort of leggings or tights; that is definitely a popular look for the target market aged kids. But otherwise, do not want; this outfit strikes me as incomplete and of middling quality for the asking price.
On the plus side, mix-and match versatility is in its favor with the plain top and nice boots, as well as the hat if you're a hat person.