I just got the Mattel version in the mail today...its nice but it seems like the fabric is stiffer then I remember the premattel version to be. I also dont think it looks very good with the the paniers in her underpinnings set. There just simply is not enough material in the skirt...B+ could be improved with more fabric in the skirt and softer fabric.
"If growing up means it will be beneath my dignity to climb a tree, I'll never grow up" - Peter Pan Musical -
My dolls: Addy Kirsten Samantha and #39 (Katya)
My daughters' dolls: Nellie ; Kanani and Molly (Molly has been usurped by my younger one)
Wanting: Emily, Jess and a Magic Attic Club