I really love the dress! I had a plaid dress for Christmas one year as a girl, and always wanted this for Addy. I found it for a reasonable price on eBay.
Mine is PM. The material seems quite sturdy. It fluffs out easily, and stays that way. The green ribbon is surprisingly long. The one sleeve is a bit wide, like the elastic stretched out a bit, but it may just be due to the fact I bought is used.
Otherwise, totally as A from me. Need to try it out on my modern doll as well at some point.
Note: I had a colour filter on my camera, and was too lazy to take it off, so it isn't quite this bright. LOL