I'm obviously a bit late with this, but I had to review this doll... I found Elizabeth at a thrift store with Nellie and Kailey for under $5 each. At the time, I already had Molly and Samantha. Anyway, I would give Elizabeth an A because I love the Josefina face and she really is a very beautiful doll with her hair and eye combination. Her hair is also very glossy and shiny. Even though I kind of got a deal on mine I would still have paid the retail price for her. The only disappointment is in her not looking like Lizzie did in the books.