This dress is beautiful! I give it an A. It looks especially nice on Chrissa, not so much on Mia. It's dressy, but not as delicate as many AG party dresses -- it is easy for my 5-year-old to get on and off and looks like it will withstand lots of play. The shoes are cute, too!
I just got this outfit today, planning to save it for a Christmas gift, but my DD is sick so I gave it to her to cheer her up. Since she won't get Mia (her first 18" doll) until Christmas, we put the outfit on her Bitty Baby. It is super cute on Sophie Mae Louise, if a little old for a baby!, and everything fits well, except for the tank, which is a tiny bit tight around Bitty's shoulders, but it's hidden under the adorable jacket. I even like the boots and didn't have any trouble with them -- maybe they are a little easier to get on and off the Bitty Baby's feet? I will try to add pics soon so you can see how it fits the smaller dolls.