Butterfly Garden PJ's + Charm (2012-2014)

This set contains a shirt, pants, slippers and a charm, I got it from American Girl in July 2012. So the outfit looked great in the box, cute shirt, cute pants, adorable slippers. The shirt is snug and a pain to get off, but it is cute it pairs nicely with jeans as a regular shirt as well. Once it was put on the doll however, I saw there was a seam broken on one of the shoulders and the back sticks up oddly. The pants are snug (especially in the hips) but they look fine and at least the seams were intact. I was glad that they were hemmed instead of raw edges like some AG outfits have been. The slippers are the best part, soft comfy and with adorable butterflies on the toes and a nice sturdy sole so the doll can stand fine. They do have the giant tags, but they are sewn on in the toes and are hidden when the slippers are on the doll. I do like the turquoise colour and the butterfly motif (reminds me of Jess' PJ's), but the material seems stiff and uncomfortable for PJs. American Girl is sending a replacement set, hopefully it is better. C (because the slippers really are adorable)
ETA: The replacement set came today. The shirt is a thousand times better, the seams are intact, it fits better and the back lays better. The pants seem slightly roomier as well. I just wish the first one had been this nice and saved me and AG the trouble. The replacement set gets a B+