Dress – AThis is a very flattering dress. I love the festive red and black plaid, the black lace trim and velvet ribbon, and the sheer white lace at the neckline and white cuffs. It all just looks so sophisticated and fancy, while providing a unique addition to Samantha’s wardrobe. I honestly couldn’t tell you if it’s historically accurate, but it certainly feels “Victorian-inspired,” and unlike some of BeForever Samantha’s other offerings, I think that works very well here.
I’d been worried about the fit since my Samantha is a PC girl and this outfit came out at a time when AG was making their clothing notoriously tight, but it isn’t as bad as I feared. It is a bit tight and closing the Velcro can be a struggle, but once it’s on, it doesn’t look tight. In fact, I think it looks very flattering. That being said, be aware that you’re in for a bit of difficulty if you want to get this for a PC-era doll. It’s doable, but it’s definitely a bit tight.
As an aside, I love that it uses non-stick Velcro. There’s still a chance of snagging the lace, so I’d advise the kids (and adults) use care, but it’s a definite improvement over the normal Velcro.
Samantha in her dress! Pardon the blurry image - my phone camera isn't great.
Tights – A+Standard AG tights. They’re thick enough with sufficient stretch to fit on a chunkier PC doll. No complaints here!
Boots – A+I love these boots! They’re mid-calf length, made of a sturdy velvet, and feature a cute velvet bow on the front. They’re also the first boots I’ve owned that have a little heel! To my surprise, the shoes are well-balanced and the doll doesn’t tip forward or fall over. It’s easy to put them on – they just Velcro up the back with non-stick Velcro and there’s plenty of room to do this without snagging the tights.
Tights and boots
Hairbow – A+I get a lot of use out of this hairbow. It’s a white lace, permanently-tied bow on a stretchy hair tie. It’s easy to tie, it’s simple, and it’s very easy to pair with other outfits. I’m very not a hair person, but I don’t have any problems with this bow.
Tea Tray – A+The tea try is decently-weighted and feels like tin or another light metal. It has a lovely shine and looks lovely on a table. The one downside is that it’s easy to mark it up with fingerprints, which hasn’t yet been a problem for me, but I could see it bothering some collectors.
Napkin – A+A simple, white cloth napkin with an embroidered border and a rose in each corner. It’s delightfully delicate and looks very suited to the sort of fancy party that Samantha would likely be hosting or attending.
Teacup, Saucer, and Teapot – A+These are all made of glass or porcelain and feature a charming rose pattern. I love that they’re made of something other than plastic and look like smaller sized versions of the real thing. The cup and saucer also have a nice faux-gold border that looks very elegant.
Petit Fours – A+These are pretty standard for AG’s current food offerings, but I’m admittedly a sucker for tiny food items. I’m not even bothered that these are connected because they look so nice. I’m perhaps a little disappointed that there wasn’t a plate provided for them (surely, Samantha won’t be eating these off the napkin!), but my sister just got me a little dessert display tray for the dolls, so they’ll go nicely in that.
The whole set on the tray.
Good Value?I paid the full retail cost of $64 when this set came out. In 2014, I didn’t have as much disposable income as I do now, but I still felt that it was a fair price for everything this set comes with. There are a lot of pieces in this set and all of them are good quality, so I’m very happy with the value.
Overall – A+When Samantha was re-released with her BeForever collection, I honestly wasn’t impressed with it…aside for this set. The holiday set nabbed my attention as soon as it was released and I was more than happy to add it to my collection. I don’t have Samantha’s original cranberry dress, but with this outfit, I don’t think I’ll really need it. I like this dress so much that I’m happy to have it as Samantha’s Christmas dress. It’s easily one of my favourite pieces that AG has released in the last few years.