For Bitty: OK, we established the shoes are horrid, cheap plastic, ill fitting :P. The suit and towel are nice and age appropriate. Reminds me of set from Gymboree. Grade: B
For Big Girls: The shoes actually fit better, but are still cheapy. Suit fits fine, but pattern a bit young. Grade: B-
In Conclusion: This set is probably the best swimsuit for bitty, but it's sad that AG didn't add the detail on the shoes and 3 flowers intead of just 1, so it looked the book...that (and better quality of the shoes) would have made this spectacular.